The Most-Rated Mystery Audiobooks
According to The Books Insider's catalog data, 2,616 unabridged Mystery audiobooks in our catalog carry store ratings. These are the 25 with the most ratings.
The Mystery shelf sits under Romance on the store.
The list
| # | Title | Author | Length |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Lights Out: An Into Darkness Novel | Navessa Allen | 13.6 hrs |
| 2 | Shelter in Place | Nora Roberts | 15 hrs |
| 3 | Hideaway | Nora Roberts | 15.9 hrs |
| 4 | Broken Country (Reese's Book Club) | Clare Leslie Hall | 9.2 hrs |
| 5 | Caught Up | Navessa Allen | 10.7 hrs |
| 6 | Under Currents | Nora Roberts | 14.7 hrs |
| 7 | A Broken Blade | Melissa Blair | 13.4 hrs |
| 8 | Hot Blooded | Lisa Jackson | 15.6 hrs |
| 9 | The Mountain Between Us | Charles Martin | 10 hrs |
| 10 | Inheritance: The Lost Bride Trilogy, Book 1 | Nora Roberts | 14.5 hrs |
| 11 | See Me | Nicholas Sparks | 14.5 hrs |
| 12 | Legacy | Nora Roberts | 15 hrs |
| 13 | Nightwork | Nora Roberts | 16.4 hrs |
| 14 | Game On: An Into Darkness Novel | Navessa Allen | 12.4 hrs |
| 15 | Northern Lights | Nora Roberts | 15.2 hrs |
| 16 | This Story Might Save Your Life | Tiffany Crum | 10.7 hrs |
| 17 | Under Your Scars | Ariel N. Anderson | 19 hrs |
| 18 | Ambush: A Small-Town Romantic Suspense | Colleen Coble | 9.9 hrs |
| 19 | The Mirror: The Lost Bride Trilogy, Book 2 | Nora Roberts | 14.4 hrs |
| 20 | You Shouldn’t Have Come Here | Jeneva Rose | 8 hrs |
| 21 | Identity | Nora Roberts | 15.2 hrs |
| 22 | Outfox | Sandra Brown | 14 hrs |
| 23 | High Noon | Nora Roberts | 16.6 hrs |
| 24 | The Darkest Hour | Maya Banks | 10.8 hrs |
| 25 | Tailspin | Sandra Brown | 13 hrs |
Ordered by the number of store ratings, most first; the counts are used only for ordering and never shown. A rating count measures popularity, never quality. Computed from unabridged English-language audiobooks in The Books Insider catalog (store data read November 3, 2026); children's titles are not ranked. Methodology.
Listen to any of these free
New members at audiobooks.com get three free audiobooks with the trial.
Separately, the store's catalog carries more than 10,000 audiobooks that are always free to stream.
Start listening free