The Books Insiderindependent audiobook data

The Most-Rated Mystery & Thriller Audiobooks

According to The Books Insider's catalog data, 1,046 unabridged Mystery & Thriller audiobooks in our catalog carry store ratings. These are the 25 with the most ratings.

The Mystery & Thriller shelf sits under Teen & YA on the store.

The list

#TitleAuthorLength
1TwilightStephenie Meyer12.9 hrs
2New MoonStephenie Meyer14.9 hrs
3Breaking DawnStephenie Meyer20.5 hrs
4EclipseStephenie Meyer16.4 hrs
5Miss Peregrine's Home for Peculiar ChildrenRansom Riggs9.7 hrs
6One of Us Is LyingKaren M. McManus10.7 hrs
7A Good Girl's Guide to MurderHolly Jackson10.9 hrs
8Thirteen Reasons WhyJay Asher6.4 hrs
9Inheritance GamesJennifer Lynn Barnes10.8 hrs
10Battlefield Earth: A Saga of the Year 3000L. Ron Hubbard45.9 hrs
11LegendMarie Lu7.8 hrs
12Good Girl, Bad Blood: The Sequel to A Good Girl's Guide to MurderHolly Jackson10.8 hrs
13Firekeeper's DaughterAngeline Boulley14.2 hrs
14The AlchemystMichael Scott10 hrs
15One of Us Is Lying: The international bestseller in the twisty thriller trilogyKaren M. McManus10.7 hrs
16The Hawthorne LegacyJennifer Lynn Barnes10.4 hrs
17That's Not My NameMegan Lally9 hrs
18The Wild LandsPaul Greci9.7 hrs
19As Good As Dead: The Finale to A Good Girl's Guide to MurderHolly Jackson15.1 hrs
20Five Total StrangersNatalie D. Richards7.9 hrs
21Girls with Sharp SticksSuzanne Young10.6 hrs
22Hush, HushBecca Fitzpatrick8.9 hrs
23Pretty Little LiarsSara Shepard7.1 hrs
24Into the Pit: An AFK Book (Five Nights at Freddy’s: Fazbear Frights #1)Elley Cooper5 hrs
25One of Us Is Next: The Sequel to One of Us Is LyingKaren M. McManus10.4 hrs

Ordered by the number of store ratings, most first; the counts are used only for ordering and never shown. A rating count measures popularity, never quality. Computed from unabridged English-language audiobooks in The Books Insider catalog (store data read November 3, 2026); children's titles are not ranked. Methodology.

Listen to any of these free

New members at audiobooks.com get three free audiobooks with the trial.

Separately, the store's catalog carries more than 10,000 audiobooks that are always free to stream.

Start listening free